I need to be careful here. Caldwell is one of my former doctoral students. I refereed this book in manuscript for the press, and then wrote an endorsement for it. I am one of the author’s biggest fans. But notwithstanding my bias, I can say in all honestly that this is a marvelous survey of American revival thinking from 1740 to 1840, or the time of the Great Awakening through that of the Second Great Awakening. It handles its controversial subject matter accurately, fairly, and with keen historical insight, even challenging contemporary views of conversion based on the story that it tells.
Noting that conversion experiences and narratives have long been central to evangelical identity, Caldwell contends that the theologies undergirding these phenomena are often overlooked, to the detriment of historical understanding of evangelicals and the practice of evangelism by Christians in the present. We have several good books on parts of the story Caldwell tells. But not until now have we had an expert overview of the whole–let alone one that avoids theological partisanship and contemporary denominational wrangling.
As the author of a first-rate monograph on Jonathan Edwards’ doctrine of communion in the Spirit, co-author of a sourcebook on Edwards and the Trinity, and professor of church history at a Southern Baptist seminary, Caldwell is well-placed to guide readers reliably through the often-dense thickets of early American revival thought.
Here is the book’s table of contents:
Chapter 1. Moderate Evangelical Revival Theology in the First Great Awakening
Chapter 2. First Great Awakening Alternatives: The Revival Theologies of Andrew Croswell and Jonathan Edwards
Chapter 3. Revival Theology in the New Divinity Movement
Chapter 4. Congregationalist and New School Presbyterian Revival Theology in the Second Great Awakening
Chapter 5. Methodist Revival Theology in the Second Great Awakening
Chapter 6. Revival Theologies among Early American Baptists
Chapter 7. The New Measures Revival Theology of Charles Finney
Chapter 8. Two Responses to Modern Revival Theology: Princeton Seminary and theRestoration Movement
Highly recommended for historians of American evangelical religion, college and seminary classes in American church history, and readers with an interest in the doctrine of conversion.